Buying Off the Plan and the Risks Agents Skip Over
The display suite is the best designed room in the whole project. Soft lighting, a scale model under glass, a render of a balcony at golden hour with a woman holding a glass of wine, and a price list that asks for ten per cent today to...

The display suite is the best designed room in the whole project. Soft lighting, a scale model under glass, a render of a balcony at golden hour with a woman holding a glass of wine, and a price list that asks for ten per cent today to secure a two bedroom apartment that will be finished in about three years. Everything in that room is built to make a long wait feel like a decision you are lucky to be offered.
I am not against buying off the plan. I have watched two friends do well out of it and one get badly hurt, and the difference between them had nothing to do with picking the right building. It came down to what the contract allowed the developer to change, and what the apartment was worth on the day the bank looked at it rather than the day the deposit was paid. Those are the two things nobody at the display suite will raise with you.
You are signing for a description, not a property
When you buy an established home you inspect the actual thing, and the contract describes something you have stood inside. Off the plan, the contract describes a set of drawings and a schedule of finishes, and the building that eventually exists has to match that description closely enough, not exactly.
How closely is written in the contract, and the numbers are more generous to the developer than most buyers expect. Floor area tolerances of around five per cent are common, which on a 72 square metre apartment is three and a half square metres, roughly the size of a small bedroom's worth of floor. Finishes are usually specified as a named product or equivalent, and equivalent is decided by the developer. Internal layouts can shift to accommodate engineering changes. None of this is fraud. It is all in the document, in the part that reads as boilerplate.
Read the variation clause first, before the price. You are looking for what counts as a minor variation, who decides, and whether you have any right to walk away if the change is material. If the clause lets the developer change anything at all so long as the overall value is not reduced, that is a very wide door, and the valuation at the end is theirs to argue.
The valuation gap is the risk that actually bites
Here is the mechanic that catches people, and it has nothing to do with construction quality. Your lender does not value the apartment when you sign. It values the apartment about four to six weeks before settlement, two or three years later, and it lends a percentage of that number rather than of the price you agreed.
Work it through. You sign at 620,000 with a ten per cent deposit of 62,000, planning to borrow 80 per cent. Three years later the building completes and the valuation comes in at 575,000, because four similar towers finished in the same suburb in the same eighteen months. The bank will lend 80 per cent of 575,000, which is 460,000. You still owe 620,000 under a contract you cannot walk away from, so you need 160,000 rather than the 124,000 you planned for. The shortfall is 36,000 in cash, found inside the fourteen to twenty one days the settlement notice gives you.
This is the same problem as a short valuation on an established purchase, except you get no cooling off period and no renegotiation. We covered the established version in what to do when a bank valuation lands below your offer, and almost none of those options exist here. The lesson I took from watching it happen: treat your deposit as the smaller half of the money you may need.
Why the tax saving argument is weaker than it sounds
The two selling points you will hear most are that off the plan reduces your transfer duty, and that you lock in today's price while the market runs away from you. Both are true in isolation and both get oversold.
The duty concession, where it exists, is real money and worth having. It is also a one off saving of a few per cent, which is smaller than the valuation swing described above and smaller than the premium many off the plan projects carry in the first place. A new build is priced against other new builds, with marketing and sales commission inside that price, and you are often paying a premium for new rather than receiving a discount for waiting.
The locked in price argument assumes prices rise over the construction period. Sometimes they do. The pattern worth knowing is that new apartment stock tends to complete in clusters, because developers respond to the same signals at the same time, and a cluster of completions in one suburb puts downward pressure on exactly the resale and rental market your apartment lands in. You are not making a bet on the city. You are making a bet on your postcode in a specific eighteen month window three years out, and that is a much narrower bet than the brochure implies.
The clauses to read before you sign anything
Give the contract to a conveyancer or solicitor who has reviewed off the plan contracts before, not just any property lawyer. Ask them to report specifically on the items below. The cost of that review runs a few hundred dollars more than a standard contract review and is the best value money in the whole process.
| Clause | What to look for | Why it matters |
|---|---|---|
| Sunset date | A specific date, usually 36 to 60 months out | If the project is not finished by then either party may be able to end the contract, and in a rising market that favours the developer |
| Variation rights | What counts as minor, and who decides | Decides whether you can object to a changed layout or a substituted finish |
| Area tolerance | The permitted percentage, often around five | A smaller apartment than you paid for, with no price adjustment |
| Deposit handling | Held in a trust account, or released to the developer | Determines what you recover if the developer fails |
| Defects liability | The period and the process for reporting | Your only mechanism for getting problems fixed after settlement |
| Strata budget and levies | The estimated levies and what they assume | First year estimates are frequently optimistic, especially for lifts and pools |
On the last row, ask for the draft strata plan and budget rather than the summary. Reading one properly is a skill in itself, and our guide to reading a strata report before you buy an apartment applies to the draft just as much as to an existing building.
What to do at each stage of the wait
If you go ahead, the three years are not passive. Put a bank guarantee or deposit bond in place instead of cash where the contract allows it, so your deposit keeps earning somewhere you control. Do not get formal loan approval at signing, because approvals typically last around three months and will expire many times over before you need one. Keep a file with every variation notice the developer sends, dated, because the pattern of changes is your early warning.
Six months out, start watching listings and completed sales in the same postcode, particularly other new towers. That is your valuation forecast, and it is free. Three months out, talk to a broker about what the lending environment looks like and whether the lender you planned on still writes loans on that building, because some lenders cap their exposure to a single development at around fifteen or twenty per cent of its units.
Then at practical completion, inspect before settlement with a building consultant who works on new apartments, not a general home inspector. Expect a list. Two of my friend's eleven defects were still unresolved fourteen months later, which is ordinary rather than scandalous, and is a reason to hold something back if the contract lets you. Your settlement costs will also be larger than an established purchase in a few quiet ways, which the breakdown in the upfront costs of buying a home sets out.
Off the plan suits a particular buyer: someone with a cash buffer well beyond the deposit, a long horizon, no deadline to move in, and a tolerance for the apartment arriving slightly different from the drawing. If you are stretching to the deposit and need somewhere to live by a fixed date, this is the wrong product, however good the render looks.
FAQ
How much deposit do you need to buy off the plan?
Ten per cent is the usual figure, often payable as a bank guarantee or deposit bond rather than cash. Budget for more than that at settlement in case the valuation comes in low.
What happens if the valuation is lower at settlement?
You still owe the contract price, and the lender lends against the lower figure, so you cover the difference in cash within the settlement period. There is no renegotiation and no cooling off.
What is a sunset clause?
A date by which the project must be completed and registered. If it passes, one or both parties may end the contract, so check who holds that right and whether consent is required.
Can you sell before settlement?
Sometimes, through an assignment or nomination, if the contract permits it and the developer consents. Many contracts restrict it or charge a fee, so check before you rely on it as an exit.
More in Buying
Buying
Making a Pre-Auction Offer and When Agents Take It
A buyer rang me on a Tuesday in week two of a campaign and offered 30,000 dollars under the quoted range, conditional on...
Buying
Bidding at a House Auction and How to Set Your Limit
Forty people in a front garden on a Saturday morning, and only three of them are going to bid.
Buying
Sewer Scope Inspection Before You Buy an Older House
The building inspection came back clean, the offer is ready, and nobody has looked at the pipe that carries every flush from...