Making a Pre-Auction Offer and When Agents Take It
A buyer rang me on a Tuesday in week two of a campaign and offered 30,000 dollars under the quoted range, conditional on finance, with a six week settlement. He told me he did not want to go through the auction.

A buyer rang me on a Tuesday in week two of a campaign and offered 30,000 dollars under the quoted range, conditional on finance, with a six week settlement. He told me he did not want to go through the auction. I passed it on because I had to, the owners said no in about four minutes, and on the Saturday the house sold for 71,000 dollars above what he had offered. He had not made an offer. He had made an enquiry with a number attached.
Three weeks later, on a different listing, a buyer sent through a signed contract at a number that made the owners sit down, with no conditions and a deadline of 5pm the next day. That one sold on the Wednesday. Same market, same agent, same two week point in a campaign. The difference was entirely in how the offer was built, and after twelve years of taking these to sellers I can tell you the construction matters more than the dollar figure does.
Why most pre-auction offers get rejected without discussion
Understand what the seller has already spent. A standard auction campaign costs the owners somewhere between 4,000 and 9,000 dollars in marketing, paid up front or added to the settlement statement. Four weeks of advertising, photography, a board out the front, and a floor plan. By week two they are halfway through something they have paid for, and stopping early feels like throwing part of it away even when the number is good.
Then there is the information problem. Two weeks into a campaign the agent knows how many groups have come through, who has asked for a contract, and who has booked an inspection. The owners know roughly the same. Nobody yet knows what the property will fetch under competition, because that is the one thing only auction day produces. An offer that arrives before that knowledge exists is asking the seller to accept certainty in exchange for giving up the upside, and the price of certainty is higher than most buyers want to pay.
The third reason is more ordinary. Many sellers have already made plans around the auction date. They have booked movers, lined up a purchase of their own, or told family they will know by the 29th. A sale on the 14th sounds like a gift until you realise it moves their settlement forward by a fortnight and they now have nowhere to live.
Reading whether the campaign is actually weak
A pre-auction offer succeeds almost exclusively on campaigns that are not going well, and the signals are visible from outside if you know where to look. I used to brief sellers with a version of this table every second week of a campaign.
| Signal | Strong campaign | Weak campaign |
|---|---|---|
| Groups through the first open | 25 or more | Under 12 |
| Contracts requested by week two | 5 to 10 | 1 or 2 |
| Building and pest reports ordered | Several | None |
| Price guide movement | Revised upward | Unchanged or quietly dropped |
| Agent's tone when you ask | Vague, relaxed, no urgency | Calls you back within the hour |
| Days on market across the suburb | Under 25 | Over 45 |
Ask the agent directly how many contracts have gone out. Most will tell you, because a high number helps them and a low number is hard to hide once you have asked twice. Also watch for a second campaign on a property that was passed in earlier in the year, since those sellers have already had the market tell them something and are far more receptive.
Rain matters more than people credit. A campaign with two wet Saturdays out of four arrives at auction day with half the crowd it should have, and an agent who knows it. Those are the campaigns where a pre-auction offer gets taken seriously in week three.
The advice to never show your hand is wrong
Buyer forums and a fair few buyer's agents will tell you to stay quiet before auction, on the reasoning that an offer reveals your limit and hands the agent ammunition. I understand the logic and I think it is backwards, because it misreads what the agent actually learns.
A weak offer does hand over ammunition. Offer 30,000 dollars under the range and you have told me three things: you want the house, you will be there on Saturday, and you have more money than that. I will now quote the range to other buyers with more confidence, and on auction day I know there is at least one bidder in the crowd. That buyer paid a real price for making a cheap offer.
A properly built offer does something different. It forces a decision while the seller still has four weeks of uncertainty ahead, and it does it in a form the seller can accept on the spot. Signed contract, no finance clause, deposit ready, and an expiry. That combination is the strongest instrument a buyer has in a soft campaign, and refusing to use it out of a general principle about secrecy costs people houses. The question is not whether to make a pre-auction offer, it is whether this particular campaign is the kind where one works.
Expect the agent to shop it. We are legally obliged to present offers and commercially motivated to test them against other buyers, so your offer will become a phone call to four other people. That is not bad faith, it is the job, and a short expiry is your defence against it dragging on for a week.
How to build one that gets taken to the owners properly
Do the work first. That means finance approved rather than pre-approved where you can get it, a building and pest inspection already completed at 600 to 900 dollars of your own money, and the contract reviewed by your conveyancer. All of that happens before you name a number, which is why a serious pre-auction offer takes about a week to prepare and cannot be done on a Thursday afternoon.
The number needs to beat what the property would make under competition, not what the price guide says. Guides sit under expected results in most markets, frequently by 5 to 10 percent, so an offer at the top of the range is usually an offer below the likely sale price. Work out your own walk away figure the way you would for the day itself, then offer close to it, because there is no second round. If the offer fails you are bidding on Saturday anyway, as covered in the piece on bidding at a house auction and setting your limit.
Put it in writing by email, attach the signed contract, state the deposit amount and the settlement period, and give it a deadline of 24 to 48 hours. Short enough to prevent a shopping tour, long enough that the owners can reasonably get advice. One more thing worth asking for: that the auction be cancelled on acceptance, in writing, since a seller who accepts and then takes the property to auction anyway has wasted your inspection money. Check your finance is genuinely current before you remove the condition, because a lapsed approval is the most common way these fall over, which the piece on home loan pre-approval and how long it lasts goes into. There is more on the buying process in the buying section.
FAQ
How early in the campaign should I offer?
Week two or three. Week one is too early, because the sellers have not yet had a chance to be disappointed and the marketing has barely run. The final week is usually too late, since by then the owners can see the finish line and will almost always take the auction.
Do I have to remove the finance condition?
Not legally, but a conditional offer before auction is rarely competitive. The whole appeal to a seller is certainty, and a finance clause is exactly the uncertainty they are trying to escape. If you cannot go unconditional, your offer will be read as a starting position rather than a decision.
Will the agent tell me what the sellers want?
Some will give you a figure, and that figure is usually the reserve plus a cushion. Treat it as information rather than instruction. Reserves commonly are not finalised until the week of the auction, so anything quoted in week two is a guess with a direction behind it.
What if they reject it and then it passes in?
You are in a strong position, as long as you were the highest bidder on the day, since that usually comes with the first right to negotiate. Many buyers whose pre-auction offer was knocked back end up buying the same house within the hour, occasionally for less than they originally offered.
More in Buying
Buying
Bidding at a House Auction and How to Set Your Limit
Forty people in a front garden on a Saturday morning, and only three of them are going to bid.
Buying
Sewer Scope Inspection Before You Buy an Older House
The building inspection came back clean, the offer is ready, and nobody has looked at the pipe that carries every flush from...
Buying
Pest Inspection Before Buying a House and What It Covers
The house looks solid, the building report came back mostly clean, and the agent says nobody bothers with a separate pest check...