Ruchin logo RuchinHomes bought, fixed and sold
Neighbourhoods

How to Check Comparable Sales in a Suburb Before You Bid

A couple stood next to me at an auction in 2019 holding a printout of an automated valuation that said 940,000. The hammer came down at 1,118,000 and they walked back to the car looking as though somebody had cheated. Nobody had.

A kitchen table with printed property listings, a notepad showing handwritten price figures and a laptop open on a sold listings page

A couple stood next to me at an auction in 2019 holding a printout of an automated valuation that said 940,000. The hammer came down at 1,118,000 and they walked back to the car looking as though somebody had cheated. Nobody had. Three houses within four streets had sold above 1.1 million in the previous ten weeks, two of them at auction with more than eight registered bidders, and all three were on the public record before that Saturday.

I called a lot of auctions over twelve years, and the buyers who were never shocked by the result were the ones who had done one unglamorous piece of homework. They had looked at what comparable houses in that suburb actually sold for, in person, and written a number on a piece of paper before auction day. It takes about six hours spread over three weekends and it is the cheapest insurance available to a buyer.

What makes a sale comparable

Agents and valuers use the word loosely, so here is the version that holds up. A comparable sale is one where a buyer with your brief would have been choosing between that house and the one you want.

That means the same suburb, or an immediately adjoining pocket with the same school catchment and the same train line. It means sold within the last six months, stretching to nine if your suburb is quiet. It means similar land size, similar number of bedrooms and bathrooms, and critically a similar condition, because renovated and unrenovated versions of the same floor plan can sit 200,000 apart in the same street.

Three sales you understand properly beat thirty you have skimmed. Volume is what automated models already have. Judgement about condition is the thing you can add that they cannot.

What is not comparable: a sale in the next suburb because the price suits your budget, a sale from eighteen months ago, a sale of a two bedroom unit when you are buying a house, and anything that sold between related parties. That last one appears on the record at a number that reflects a family arrangement rather than a market, and it will sit in your data quietly dragging your estimate down.

Where the numbers come from, and what each source hides

Four sources, in descending order of how much I trust them.

The state land registry or valuer general data. This is the settled, legally recorded transfer price. It is the only source with no incentive attached. The catch is lag: in most states the record appears somewhere between four weeks and four months after settlement, which can be six months after the contract was signed. In a moving market you are looking at history.

Sold listings on the big portals. Fast, usually accurate on price when a price is shown, and they carry the photographs, which is where the condition information lives. The hole is that agents are not obliged to publish the sold price and in some states commonly do not. A listing marked sold with no figure is a gap in your data, not an absence of a sale.

Saturday auction results. Reported same day by the agencies and the industry bodies, which makes them the freshest signal available. The clearance rate quoted on the news is a blunt instrument, but the individual results for your suburb are useful, and the number of registered bidders is more useful still. Treat the reported figures as indicative until they appear in the registry.

The agent's own comparables. Ask for them, read them, and understand what you are reading. I compiled these for sellers for years. The selection is honest and also curated, because I chose the sales that supported the campaign. An agent giving you five comparables has not lied about any of them and has almost certainly left out the awkward one.

Days on market belongs beside every figure you collect, because a 1.2 million sale after one week and a 1.2 million sale after eleven weeks describe different markets. We go into what that number reveals in what days on market tell you about a suburb.

The counter-take: the automated estimate is fine, the price guide is not

Buyers are routinely told to ignore portal estimates and trust the agent's price guide. I would reverse that, and I say it as somebody who wrote price guides for a living.

An automated estimate is a model with a published confidence band. It is wrong in understandable ways: it cannot see that the kitchen was replaced in 2023, it cannot see the main road at the back, and it misses badly on anything unusual. Read it as a sanity check with a plus or minus ten percent band around it and it is genuinely useful, particularly for spotting when your own number has drifted far from the data.

A price guide is a marketing instrument. It exists to generate inspections. The guide is normally set at or near the bottom of the vendor's acceptable range, sometimes below it, and the campaign is designed so that competition carries the price above it. Underquoting laws in New South Wales and Victoria mean the guide has to be a reasonable estimate and has to be revised if evidence changes, which has tightened things since the mid 2010s. It has not changed the incentive. In the suburbs I worked, the winning bid landed somewhere between five and fifteen percent above the opening guide often enough that I stopped treating it as a surprise.

So budget off your own comparables, use the estimate as a cross check, and treat the guide as information about the agent's strategy rather than about the property. If the guide sits well below every comparable you have found, that is not a bargain appearing. That is a campaign working.

Building your own list

This is the whole process. Do it before you fall in love with a specific house, because the number you write while calm is the number you will need when you are not.

  1. Pull twelve months of sold listings for the suburb, filtered to your bedroom count and a land size range of plus or minus 25 percent. You will typically get between 40 and 150 results. Save them somewhere you can sort by date.
  2. Cut it to the last six months and to houses you would have considered. You should be down to between eight and twenty. If you have fewer than six, widen the window before you widen the geography, because time is a smaller distortion than location.
  3. Walk or inspect at least five of them before they settle. Open homes are public. Go to the ones that are still on the market in your price range and go to the auctions of the ones that are not, even when you have no intention of bidding. One Saturday of this teaches you more than a month of reading.
  4. Write down the condition of each, in your own words. Original kitchen, new bathroom, needs rewiring, north facing yard, backs onto the school. Three or four lines each. This is the column the automated model does not have.
  5. Adjust for the differences, in whole units. Not percentages. In most suburbs an extra bathroom, off street parking, 100 square metres of land or a renovated kitchen each carry a figure that locals will quote you if you ask. Add and subtract those from your closest comparables rather than trying to model the whole market.
  6. Write one number and one walk away number on paper, and date it. Carry it with you. The paper exists so that the person who stood in the kitchen and felt something can be overruled by the person who did the research three weeks earlier.

Two practical notes. Attend the auctions of your comparables if you can, because a result tells you the price and the room tells you the depth of demand. And keep your list going after you lose one, since the sales you lose become your best comparables for the next attempt. If you have not stood in an auction crowd before, how bidding at a house auction actually works is worth reading first.

The research also feeds back into the softer questions, because the comparable that sold 90,000 under the others usually has a reason, and finding out what it was is how you learn to read a neighbourhood before you make an offer.

FAQ

How many comparable sales do I need?

Six to ten that you understand properly. Below six, your estimate is sensitive to one odd result. Above about fifteen you are adding noise rather than confidence.

How recent does a comparable have to be?

Six months is the working rule, and three months in a market moving quickly. Past nine months you are measuring a different market, and you will need to adjust for the trend rather than use the figure directly.

Can I get sold prices for free?

Mostly yes. Portal sold sections, agency results pages and the state registry cover most of it at no cost. Paid property reports mainly buy you convenience and a tidier presentation of the same records.

What if the agent will not tell me what a house sold for?

Ask again after settlement, when there is no reason to withhold it, or wait for the registry record. Meanwhile treat the undisclosed sale as a data point you do not have, and build your number from the ones you do. More of this sits in the neighbourhoods section.

TL
Thaddeus Lorne

Thaddeus worked as a sales agent for twelve years and called more than three hundred auctions before he moved to writing about them.

More posts by Thaddeus

More in Neighbourhoods

01doorganico 084goad 3hot8 4465456 after5internprogram ahandfulofblessings ahmadpc ahomcybersecurity allodialresources annodex antiquesandperiodcollectibles aotc asianworldkashmir beedlectrics bloggertemplatefree bluefeatheragency bodyweightsolution campaign08blog carfixadvisor catstreetcollective cbstvsports cnfanspurchasing committeeof500yearsofdignityandresistance covertopsdjs cs-kaiyuangame cuestacomunicaciontotal cxoutlet dancebetgame deskgearhub destinyvillastay detectmagazine di33 diamondsteelbuildings donmo dyanadropship emarsysfinance emimattl escapechan eskitarih evautoplay everythingweddings-orlando farmzone feedviewerapp foxstudiosscratch gamevui123 gleasongrade greetingsday hacklabasu haskell iw-kaiyun jagoanproperti jilidskripsi joltbusinessfinance juegodepokergratis juegospucca kaeru-festival latestmehndidesigns lestanzediottaviano litemagazines localcommunityhero lustrsazan mariashebets menswheels newwebstechs1 nikkit ootheday oxigenvpn plurfitness prefetial probudgetcarpetcleaning psychicmrsmartin pyaten qvantor rejoignezlogis rexzbot riselayouts rwxqsgd5 sakaltime shibiaowang shop-bot skrtips spotlesshaven strcoding tetapatrium topselller uneplanteartificielle vipertechcr webtech1223411 wo-kygaming yamaha-mekar yeknava yoybuysheets zenunwa yamaha-mekar jilidskripsi ankertoto ankertoto ankertoto ankertoto