Ruchin logo RuchinHomes bought, fixed and sold
Selling

Passed In at Auction and What a Seller Should Do Next

The hammer does not come down, the auctioneer thanks everyone for coming, and within ninety seconds the people on your front lawn are walking back to their cars. That is the loneliest moment in a sale campaign.

An auctioneer and sellers talking on the front lawn of a house as the small crowd walks away after bidding stops

The hammer does not come down, the auctioneer thanks everyone for coming, and within ninety seconds the people on your front lawn are walking back to their cars. That is the loneliest moment in a sale campaign. I have stood beside sellers through it a few hundred times, and the first thing almost every one of them says is some version of the same sentence: how much do we have to drop it?

Almost always, that is the wrong question to answer in the next ten minutes. A property that passes in has not failed. It has produced a pile of information that a private sale campaign would have taken six weeks to generate, and the sellers who do well from here are the ones who read that information before they touch the price. The ones who do badly are the ones who let the disappointment in the room make the decision.

What passing in actually means

If bidding stops short of your reserve, the auctioneer passes the property in. Nothing has been sold and you are not bound to anything. In most markets the highest bidder gets the first right to negotiate with you, exclusively, for a short window that is usually measured in minutes rather than days.

That window is the part sellers do not expect. The agent will take the highest bidder into the house, often into the kitchen, and bring offers back and forth while the bidder is still holding the emotional momentum of the auction. If the property was passed in on a vendor bid rather than a genuine bid, there is nobody to negotiate with, and that is a materially different situation. Ask the agent which one happened before you say anything else, because sellers routinely confuse the two.

The contract that was on the table during the auction is still the contract. If a deal comes together in that first conversation, it is usually unconditional, which is worth real money compared with a conditional offer three weeks later.

The first hour is worth more than the first week

On the day, in order: find out how many registered bidders actually bid, find out the price at which each one stopped, and find out whether anyone who registered never bid at all. Your agent has all three numbers in their head and will not volunteer them unless asked.

Then negotiate with the highest bidder while they are still there. The gap between the top bid and your reserve is the only number that matters right now. In my experience that gap is small more often than sellers assume. Across the auctions I called, I would put it at roughly two thirds of pass ins closing within the hour, most of them within about 2 percent of where the bidding stopped. The ones that did not close were almost all cases where the reserve sat a long way above the market, not cases where the buyer was stubborn.

If the top bidder will not move, do not let them leave without a written position. Even an unsigned offer at their best number, dated, gives you something to work with on Monday and gives them a reason to keep thinking about the house.

Why dropping the price on Monday is usually a mistake

The standard advice is to relist immediately at a lower asking price, on the theory that buyers who stayed away will come back for a bargain. I gave that advice early in my career and watched it backfire often enough to stop.

Two things go wrong. A visible price cut within a week of a pass in tells every buyer still watching that you are under pressure, and the next offers come in below the number you just set rather than at it. And the buyers who did not bid mostly did not bid for a reason that had nothing to do with price: a steep driveway, a bedroom with no window, a bus route at the end of the street. Cutting 30,000 off does not fix a steep driveway.

What I would do instead is hold the price for seven to ten days and spend that time on the reasons people hesitated. If three separate groups mentioned the kitchen bench, get a quote for replacing it and put the quote in the folder at the next open home. A specific answer to a specific objection moves buyers; a lower number mostly moves your own equity.

There is an exception worth naming honestly. If no genuine bid was made at all, and inspection numbers were thin from the start, the price was wrong and pretending otherwise wastes months. In that case move decisively rather than in small steps, because a sequence of small reductions trains buyers to wait for the next one.

Reading what the auction told you

The shape of the bidding is diagnostic. This is the table I used to work through with sellers on the afternoon of a pass in.

What happenedWhat it usually meansReasonable next move
Four or more bidders, stalled just under reservePrice is right, reserve was optimisticNegotiate down to the market, not the dream
Two bidders, big jumps, stopped well shortThin demand at that levelHold price, fix the objections, relist in two weeks
One genuine bid onlyGuide price was above the marketOne clear reduction, not three small ones
No genuine bids, good crowdBuyers came to watch, not to buyReview the guide and the agent's buyer work
No genuine bids, thin crowdMarketing or presentation problemNew photos, new copy, possibly a new agent

Pay particular attention to registered bidders who never raised a hand. They registered, which means they were serious enough to show identification, and something on the day stopped them. A phone call from the agent the following morning asking plainly what held them back is the cheapest market research you will ever get, and it produces a real answer about four times in ten.

Change the campaign, not only the number

A relaunch that looks identical to the first campaign will perform like the first campaign. The listing has already been seen by the active buyers in your price bracket, so something has to be visibly different or the alerts will not fire in anyone's inbox.

The changes that earned their keep, in rough order of value: a new lead photograph, because the thumbnail decides who clicks; a rewritten first paragraph that names the thing buyers kept asking about; a different inspection time, since a Saturday 11am crowd and a Thursday 5:30pm crowd are not the same people; and a building report you commission yourself and hand out, which removes a reason to delay. If your photographs were the weak link, our notes on listing photos that make buyers book a viewing cover what is worth paying for.

This is also the point to be honest about representation. A pass in with a thin crowd and no genuine bids, after four weeks of advertising you paid for, is a question about the agent as much as the house. The standard for that judgement is in how to choose a selling agent without chasing the top quote, and the same evidence applies to the one you already have.

Is a second auction ever worth it?

Rarely, and only with a genuine reason for the reset. Going back to auction in six weeks with the same house, the same photos and the same reserve invites the same result and costs you another advertising spend, typically a few thousand depending on the market.

It can work when the first campaign was disrupted by something external, a public holiday weekend or a competing auction of a near identical house two streets away, or when a defect has since been fixed and you can say so. Otherwise I would move to a private treaty campaign with a clear, defensible asking price, set the way how to set an asking price describes, and let buyers negotiate on their own timetable. Plenty of houses that passed in on a Saturday sold well within the following month that way, at prices nobody on the lawn would have predicted.

FAQ

Do I have to sell to the highest bidder after a pass in?

No. You are not bound by anything below your reserve. The highest bidder generally gets the first chance to negotiate, but if that goes nowhere you are free to deal with anyone else afterwards.

Should I tell buyers what the reserve was?

Not as a number. Once buyers know the reserve, every subsequent conversation starts below it. Say what you will accept today instead, which is a different and more useful statement.

How long should I wait before relisting?

Seven to ten days in most cases. Long enough that the relaunch is not read as panic, short enough that the buyers from the campaign have not committed somewhere else. Waiting a month usually means starting from scratch.

Does a passed in result stay visible to buyers?

In most markets the result is recorded and easy to find, so assume any serious buyer knows. That is an argument for addressing it directly rather than pretending the campaign is new.

TL
Thaddeus Lorne

Thaddeus worked as a sales agent for twelve years and called more than three hundred auctions before he moved to writing about them.

More posts by Thaddeus

More in Selling

01doorganico 084goad 3hot8 4465456 after5internprogram ahandfulofblessings ahmadpc ahomcybersecurity allodialresources annodex antiquesandperiodcollectibles aotc asianworldkashmir beedlectrics bloggertemplatefree bluefeatheragency bodyweightsolution campaign08blog carfixadvisor catstreetcollective cbstvsports cnfanspurchasing committeeof500yearsofdignityandresistance covertopsdjs cs-kaiyuangame cuestacomunicaciontotal cxoutlet dancebetgame deskgearhub destinyvillastay detectmagazine di33 diamondsteelbuildings donmo dyanadropship emarsysfinance emimattl escapechan eskitarih evautoplay everythingweddings-orlando farmzone feedviewerapp foxstudiosscratch gamevui123 gleasongrade greetingsday hacklabasu haskell iw-kaiyun jagoanproperti jilidskripsi joltbusinessfinance juegodepokergratis juegospucca kaeru-festival latestmehndidesigns lestanzediottaviano litemagazines localcommunityhero lustrsazan mariashebets menswheels newwebstechs1 nikkit ootheday oxigenvpn plurfitness prefetial probudgetcarpetcleaning psychicmrsmartin pyaten qvantor rejoignezlogis rexzbot riselayouts rwxqsgd5 sakaltime shibiaowang shop-bot skrtips spotlesshaven strcoding tetapatrium topselller uneplanteartificielle vipertechcr webtech1223411 wo-kygaming yamaha-mekar yeknava yoybuysheets zenunwa yamaha-mekar jilidskripsi ankertoto ankertoto ankertoto ankertoto